When Should You Drop Collision and Comprehensive on an Older Car?

Run the numbers on your car in four steps.

Team LemonadeTeam Lemonade
Get a quote
when to drop collision and comprehensive insurance

Short answer: drop collision and comprehensive when your car’s value minus your deductible is small compared to what you pay each year, and no loan or lease says you can’t. That usually describes an older, paid-off car.

Here’s how to run the numbers, plus a break-even worksheet with three real-world scenarios.

TL;DR
  • Consider dropping collision and comprehensive when the most they could pay (car value minus deductible) is low next to your yearly cost.
  • If you have a car loan or lease, your lienholder almost always requires both.
  • Insurance pays actual cash value minus your deductible, not what you paid for the car.
  • At Lemonade, you can drop collision on its own, but you can’t keep collision without comprehensive.
  • Keep liability insurance no matter what, as it’s required in most states.

When should you drop collision and comprehensive coverage?

When the payout you could realistically get is too small to justify the premium. Insurance never pays more than your car is worth, so as a car ages, the math tilts away from coverage.

It’s probably time to consider dropping if:

  • Your car is paid off and not leased.
  • Collision and comprehensive together cost roughly 10% or more of your car’s value per year (a common rule of thumb, not a hard rule).
  • You could repair or replace the car from savings without real hardship.
  • Your car value minus your deductible is a small number.

Dropping both is what most people mean by when to drop full coverage. “Full coverage” isn’t an official policy type. It usually means liability insurance plus collision and comprehensive.

Comprehensive vs collision: what each one pays for

Collision helps pay to repair or replace your car after a crash with another car or an object, like a pole or guardrail. It applies even when you’re at fault.

Comprehensive helps cover damage that isn’t a crash, such as theft, vandalism, fire, hail, flooding, or a tree landing on your hood.

Neither covers other people’s cars or injuries. That’s liability insurance, and you’ll want to keep it.

Comprehensive often costs less than collision, so it can be worth keeping on an older car even after collision stops making sense. Collision coverage cost varies by car, location, and driving history.

One Lemonade rule to know: you can’t carry collision without comprehensive, but you can carry comprehensive alone. That means collision is the only one you can drop on its own.

Can you drop coverage with a car loan or lease?

Usually not. If you have a car loan or lease, your lienholder (the lender that has a claim on the car until it’s paid off) typically requires collision and comprehensive. The car is their collateral.

If you drop coverage anyway, lenders can add their own coverage and bill you for it, which tends to cost more and protects them, not you. Check your loan or lease agreement first. Once the loan is paid off, the decision is yours.

How actual cash value and your deductible set the payout

Actual cash value (ACV) is your car’s market value right before the loss. It isn’t what you paid or what a shop charges to fix it. Your payout is roughly ACV minus your deductible, the amount you pay before insurance kicks in.

If repairs cost close to (or more than) the car’s value, it may be declared a total loss. You’d get the ACV minus your deductible, not a repair. The exact threshold varies by state and insurer.

You can also shrink premiums without dropping anything. A higher deductible lowers your premium, but raises your out-of-pocket repair costs when something happens. It’s a handy middle path.

A break-even worksheet: three cars, three answers

Try the math on your own car:

  1. Look up your car’s actual cash value (ACV) on a valuation site or in local listings. That’s what your car is worth today.
  2. Subtract your deductible from that value. What’s left is your max payout, the most a claim could pay you.
  3. Add up what you pay each year for collision and comprehensive.
  4. Divide that yearly cost by your max payout. If it’s above 10%, it may be time to think about dropping coverage.

To show how it works, here are three cars. Think of these numbers as a demo. They’re not Lemonade quotes, so yours will differ.

The older sedan: drop collision

  • Value: $3,500
  • Deductible: $1,000
  • Max payout: $2,500 ($3,500 minus $1,000)
  • Yearly cost: $700 ($520 collision, $180 comprehensive)
  • Cost vs. max payout: 28% ($700 divided by $2,500)

Our take: drop collision. You’d pay $520 a year for a claim that could only pay out $2,500. Keep comprehensive if $180 feels worth it for theft or weather.

The financed SUV: keep both

  • Value: $24,000
  • Deductible: $500
  • Max payout: $23,500 ($24,000 minus $500)
  • Yearly cost: $1,400
  • Cost vs. max payout: about 6% ($1,400 divided by $23,500)

Our take: keep both. The math favors coverage, and your lender likely requires it anyway.

The paid-off truck: it’s your call

  • Value: $14,000
  • Deductible: $1,000
  • Max payout: $13,000 ($14,000 minus $1,000)
  • Yearly cost: $1,100
  • Cost vs. max payout: about 8.5% ($1,100 divided by $13,000)

Our take: it’s close, since 8.5% sits just under the 10% line. If losing the truck would hurt, keep coverage and try a higher deductible to bring your cost down. If you could replace it from savings, dropping coverage is reasonable.

The bottom line

Same math, different answers. The sedan’s yearly cost was huge next to what a claim could pay, so dropping collision made sense. The SUV was the opposite, and your lender likely wants coverage anyway. The truck landed in the middle, which is where your comfort with risk comes in.

Run the numbers on your own car, then ask one question: could you cover the loss from savings? If so, dropping coverage may save you money. If not, keeping it is probably worth the cost.

What are the risks of going without?

Without collision, you cover the repair bill or the loss of the car if you cause a crash, hit a pole, or get hit by an uninsured driver. Without comprehensive, theft, hail, fire, and flood are on you.

If you drop either, move the premium savings into a car fund so a surprise repair doesn’t become a crisis. And keep liability insurance. It covers the damage and injuries you cause to others, which can cost far more than your car is worth.

Before we go

Dropping coverage on an older car comes down to math first and comfort second. You’ve got the steps, so now you can try them on yours. With Lemonade, you can edit your coverage and compare deductibles right in the app. You’ll see how each change affects your premium before you commit. Coverage options can vary by state.

Ready to see where your car lands? Get a quote in the Lemonade app and play with the options at your own pace.

Get your quote

This article provides general educational information and is not financial or legal advice. Policy terms, coverage options, and deductible availability vary by state, and your actual policy governs in the event of a claim. If your vehicle is financed or leased, check your loan or lease agreement before removing collision or comprehensive coverage, as lenders typically require both. Always maintain at least your state’s minimum required liability coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is full coverage worth it on an older car?

Often not for collision. If your car’s value minus your deductible is small next to your yearly premium, you may pay more than you could collect. Comprehensive can still be worth it if it’s cheap.

Should I keep comprehensive on an older car?

Maybe. It usually costs less than collision and covers theft, weather, and vandalism. Keep it if replacing the car out of pocket would be tough.

Can I drop collision but keep comprehensive at Lemonade?

Yes. Lemonade lets you carry comprehensive on its own. You can’t do the reverse, because collision requires comprehensive.

How much does collision coverage cost?

It depends on your car, location, driving history, and deductible. Raising your deductible typically lowers the premium, and you can compare options in the Lemonade app.

A few quick words, because we <3 our lawyers: This post is general in nature, and any statement in it doesn’t alter the terms, conditions, exclusions, or limitations of the policies issued, which differ according to your state of residence. You’re encouraged to discuss your specific circumstances with your own professional advisors. The purpose of this post is merely to provide you with info and insights you can use to make such discussions more productive! Naturally, all comments by, or references to, third parties represent their own views, and Lemonade assumes no responsibility for them. Coverage may not be available in all states. Please note that statements about coverages, policy management, claims processes, Giveback, and customer support apply to policies underwritten by Lemonade Insurance Company or Metromile Insurance Company, a Lemonade company, sold by Lemonade Insurance Agency, LLC.  The statements do not apply to policies underwritten by other carriers.

Please note: Lemonade articles and other editorial content are meant for educational purposes only, and should not be relied upon instead of professional legal, insurance or financial advice. The content of these educational articles does not alter the terms, conditions, exclusions, or limitations of policies issued by Lemonade, which differ according to your state of residence. While we regularly review previously published content to ensure it is accurate and up-to-date, there may be instances in which legal conditions or policy details have changed since publication. Any hypothetical examples used in Lemonade editorial content are purely expositional. Hypothetical examples do not alter or bind Lemonade to any application of your insurance policy to the particular facts and circumstances of any actual claim.