7 Dog Park Red Flags You Shouldn't Ignore

This article was written in collaboration with Rover, and approved by Lemonade’s favorite Vet Dr. Stephanie Liff. 

You arrive at the dog park ready for some quality off-leash fun, but something feels off. Maybe it’s the cluster of aggressive dogs near the entrance, or the dog owners glued to their phones while chaos unfolds around them.

Dog park etiquette isn’t just about manners, it’s about safety. Knowing how to spot trouble before it starts can save you from costly accidents and keep your dog’s park experience positive.

Ready to become a dog park detective? Here are the red flags that signal it’s time to find a different spot.

1. Dog owners glued to their phones 

Nothing screams “accident waiting to happen” like dog owners who treat the park like their personal office. When people are scrolling social media instead of watching their dogs, they miss crucial dog body language cues that prevent conflicts. Attentive supervision is the foundation of good dog park etiquette, because dogs communicate constantly through body language and conflicts can escalate from friendly play to serious aggression in an instant.

Without proper supervision, dogs are more likely to get into fights, injure each other during rough play, or develop behavioral problems from unresolved conflicts. Emergency vet visits for bite wounds or trauma can cost hundreds to thousands of dollars, especially if surgery is required.

If you notice other owners aren’t paying attention to their own dog’s behavior, keep your eyes on your pooch and be ready to step in if needed. If the majority of owners seem checked out, consider finding a quieter spot or coming back when more engaged dog owners are around.

Nicole Ellis, a Certified Professional Dog Trainer (CPDT-KA) on Rover’s Pet People Panel, emphasizes the unpredictable nature of dog park dynamics:

“Dog parks can be a bit like singles bars—dogs constantly coming and going, and not all of them are going to get along. Many owners bring their dogs there to burn off pent-up energy, but that can make for an overwhelming mix, especially for calmer or more sensitive pups.”

– Nicole Ellis (CPDT-KA)

Ellis stresses the importance of staying vigilant: 

“It’s important to watch not only your own dog but also the new arrivals. A tense moment can quickly turn into a scary or even dangerous incident. Keep an eye on your dog’s body language to make sure they’re safe and comfortable. And remember—it’s always okay to leave and come back later, or to set up a smaller playdate or a doggy daycare session with a well-socialized group instead.”

– Nicole Ellis (CPDT-KA)

2. Overcrowded chaos 

When there’s barely room to move in an off-leash dog park, accidents become inevitable. Too many dogs in a small space means tangled interactions, resource competition, and stressed animals. Overcrowding makes it impossible for dog owners to monitor their pets effectively and can trigger aggressive behavior even in normally calm dogs.

Overcrowded conditions lead to trampling injuries, stress-induced fights, and accidental collisions that can cause sprains, cuts, or more serious trauma. Small dogs are particularly vulnerable when overwhelmed by enthusiastic big dogs, even during friendly interactions.

Always assess the crowd before entering through those double gates. If your dog looks anxious or there’s no room for natural dog behavior, wait for a quieter time. Many parks are less crowded during weekday mornings or early evenings.

Dr. Liff points to gate areas as a particularly vulnerable spot during busy periods:

“One of the worst incidents that arises in a crowded park is mismanagement of the gate and dogs getting out. This can happen in any situation but when things are busy, it can be hard to manage the one in/one out flow of the double gates and dogs can escape.”

-Dr. Stephanie Liff

3. Dogs that don’t respect boundaries 

Every dog owner has seen it: one dog relentlessly pursuing another that’s clearly trying to escape. Whether it’s excessive humping, persistent sniffing, or ignoring a play bow that signals “I’m done playing,” some dogs just don’t take “no” for an answer. This boundary-crossing behavior often stems from poor socialization or inadequate dog training. Young puppies and new dog arrivals are especially vulnerable, as they haven’t learned proper social skills yet.

Nicole Ellis explains that recognizing these warning signs starts with understanding canine communication:

“Good dog park manners and experiences start with reading body language. A dog that turns away, lowers their tail, hides or avoids eye contact is saying ‘I’m done.’ When another dog ignores those cues—by humping, chasing, or pestering—it’s a boundary violation that can quickly cause stress or even a fight.”

– Nicole Ellis (CPDT-KA)

Persistent boundary violations create stress and fear in targeted dogs, often leading to defensive snapping or biting. The harassing dog might also escalate their behavior, turning playful persistence into genuine aggression that can result in serious injuries for both animals.

If your dog is being pestered, calmly redirect the situation by calling your pooch away or creating physical distance. Ellis recommends taking a proactive approach to prevent these situations, “Teach your dog to respect space by practicing reliable recall and rewarding calm behavior around other dogs. Step in early if play gets too intense—redirect, take a break, or leave if needed. Respecting boundaries keeps play fun, safe, and positive for everyone. It’s always better to leave early then test it and hope nothing bad happens.” 

Don’t hesitate to speak up to the other owner, most appreciate the heads-up. If the behavior continues, it’s time to leave.

4. Signs of resource guarding

Resource guarding around toys, the water bowl, or even favorite people can turn a fun outing dangerous, fast. Dogs showing stiff body language, hovering over objects, or growling when others approach are displaying clear warning signs that many dog owners miss. This behavior is especially problematic in dog parks because resources feel limited, and female dogs or intact males (dogs that haven’t been neutered or spayed) can be particularly territorial.

Resource guarding frequently escalates into serious dog fights with multiple bite wounds requiring emergency veterinary care. These conflicts can cause puncture wounds, lacerations, and trauma that may need surgery, antibiotics, and extended recovery periods.

“Resource guarders are liabilities at a dog park especially ones where toys or food are allowed. Incidents usually involve bite wounds which can vary in severity.”

– Dr. Stephanie Liff

Remove any toys or treats you brought to avoid triggering competition. If you notice guarding behavior around the water bowl or other resources, create distance and consider leaving if the tension doesn’t ease. Never try to physically intervene in a guarding situation.

5. Poorly maintained or unsafe facilities 

Broken fences, missing double gates, muddy conditions, or scattered dog poop create hazardous conditions for both dogs and their owners. If the park looks neglected, it probably isn’t being managed safely. 

Poor maintenance increases injury risks dramatically. Broken fencing can lead to escapes, slippery surfaces cause falls, and accumulated waste spreads disease. Small children accompanying families are especially vulnerable to slips and falls in poorly maintained areas.

Nicole Ellis recommends conducting a thorough facility check before letting your dog off-leash:

“Check that the fence is tall enough (at least 4–6 feet) with no gaps or broken sections a dog could squeeze through or dig under. Ensure double-gated entry systems work properly and latch securely to prevent dogs from escaping. Look for even footing, no sharp objects, holes, broken glass, or trash that could injure paws (or be eaten if you dog likes to pick up items off the ground).

Confirm there’s shade and access to clean water (I would personally bring your own water and not share the dog park water if avoidable).”

– Nicole Ellis (CPDT-KA)

6. Unvaccinated or sick dogs 

Responsible dog park etiquette requires up-to-date vaccinations, but not all dog owners follow this rule. Dogs showing signs of illness like excessive coughing, lethargy, or visible skin conditions shouldn’t be at the park at all. Most dog park rules require current vaccinations for good reason, as unvaccinated dogs can spread serious diseases like parvo, distemper, or kennel cough throughout the dog community. Young puppies under 16 weeks are especially vulnerable since their vaccination series isn’t complete yet.

Ask park staff about vaccination requirements if they’re not posted, and don’t hesitate to leave if you suspect sick dogs are present. If it’s your first time at a new park, observe other dogs for signs of illness before committing to a play session. Contagious diseases can require expensive treatment and quarantine periods. While pet insurance can cover treatments for illnesses your pooch gets at the park, prevention through proper vaccinations and careful park selection is always your best bet. As Dr. Liff explains: 

“Since most parks are public it is impossible to regulate vaccine status and unvaccinated dogs can introduce disease into parks leading to communicable disease outbreaks.  This is especially concerning for parvovirus, distemper (in certain regions of the country), and kennel cough. If your pet is going to the park they should be well vaccinated.”

– Dr. Stephanie Liff

7. Aggressive dogs or escalating tensions 

The most serious red flag is obvious aggressive behavior including snarling, snapping, stiff body language, or dogs that won’t back down from confrontations. Some aggressive dogs might seem friendly initially but escalate quickly during play.

True aggressive behavior is different from normal dog play. Ellis explains the key differences:

“Normal play can look wild, but healthy dogs take turns, show play bows, and pause naturally to reset. Their bodies stay loose, and tails wag freely. Look for those breaks! You’ll notice when you see your dog playing with his/her best friend.”

In contrast, aggressive behavior has distinct warning signs that every dog owner should recognize.

“Aggressive behavior looks very different—think stiff posture (from head to tail), raised hackles – that hair along the back – but this also can stand up for extreme excitement, direct stares, snarling, snapping, or a dog that won’t back down. Some dogs may start off friendly but escalate quickly once aroused,” Ellis notes.

Dog fight injuries can be severe and expensive to treat, requiring emergency surgery, antibiotics, and follow-up care. Trust your instincts when something feels off—even experienced dog trainers emphasize that gut feelings matter when it comes to safety.

Ellis’s advice is straightforward:

“If a dog’s behavior makes you uneasy, trust your gut. Leave calmly and safely. Never try to break up a fight with your hands—use loud noises, water, or distraction instead.”

– Nicole Ellis (CPDT-KA)

Smart dog park strategies for safer visits

Beyond avoiding red flags, these proactive strategies can help ensure positive dog park experiences:

Before you go:

• Complete basic training classes with solid recall and obedience skills
• Choose the right section for your dog’s size (small dogs vs. big dogs)
• Bring your own water to avoid resource competition

Timing matters:

• Visit during off-peak hours (weekday mornings or early evenings)
• Start with short 15-20 minute visits for new dogs
• Leave when your dog shows signs of overstimulation or fatigue

Stay alert:

• Watch your dog’s body language throughout the visit
• Know when it’s time to take a break or head home

But even perfect dog park etiquette can’t prevent everything

Even when you follow all the dog park rules and choose the safest environments, accidents can still happen. A well-socialized dog might step on broken glass, or two friendly dogs might collide during an enthusiastic game of chase. When unexpected injuries occur, vet bills can be stressful and put an unexpected drain on your wallet.

That’s where Lemonade pet insurance comes in handy for responsible dog owners. Our pet insurance provides coverage for diagnostics, treatments, and medications for any eligible injuries your furry friend might sustain at the dog park, whether they ignored proper dog behavior signals or got hurt despite perfect training. You can even customize your policy to get coverage for things like visit fees and behavioral therapy sessions if your dog develops anxiety or aggression issues after a negative dog park experience.

If your dog gets injured during their park visit, just head to any state-licensed vet for the diagnostics, treatments, and meds they need to recover. Filing a claim with Lemonade couldn’t be easier. Just open the Lemonade app, upload the vet invoice or receipt, and include your pet’s medical records or notes from the visit. If your claim’s approved, the reimbursement goes straight to your bank account. Even better? Over 50% of Lemonade pet claims are processed instantly, and 80% are resolved within just five days.

So whether your well-trained Border Collie tears their ACL during enthusiastic off-leash play, or your friendly Golden Retriever gets bitten by an aggressive dog despite following perfect dog park etiquette, we’ve got you covered.

Before you head to the park…

Dog parks offer great socialization and exercise when everyone follows basic safety guidelines. By spotting red flags early, you can protect your dog from negative experiences while still enjoying off-leash play.

Even well-behaved dogs can find themselves in unexpected situations, which is why smart dog owners consider pet insurance part of their care strategy. The best dog training and etiquette work even better when you’re prepared for whatever comes next.

Ready to give your pooch the protection they deserve? Get a quote today, and enjoy those park visits with confidence. 

---

A few quick words, because we <3 our lawyers: This post is general in nature, and any statement in it doesn’t alter the terms, conditions, exclusions, or limitations of policies issued by Lemonade, which differ according to your state of residence. You’re encouraged to discuss your specific circumstances with your own professional advisors. The purpose of this post is merely to provide you with info and insights you can use to make such discussions more productive! Naturally, all comments by, or references to, third parties represent their own views, and Lemonade assumes no responsibility for them. Coverage and discounts may not be available in all states.